Skip to content
The Business of Practice

Prison and Mental Health Reform

It is undisputed that correctional facilities in the United States are facing a mental health crisis. Approximately 35% of individuals in state and federal prisons and over  40% of individuals in local jails have a history of mental illness, compared to 22.8% of the broader population. Yet, these facilities often lack adequate resources to address these needs. The lack of resources not only exacerbates the suffering of those incarcerated but also contributes to higher recidivism rates and increased costs for the system as a whole.

Deinstitutionalization led to “trans-institutionalization,” which is the shift of individuals with severe mental illness from psychiatric institutions to correctional facilities. While the goal of deinstitutionalization was to establish community-based care, there were insufficient resources, and jails and prisons became de facto mental health providers for the mentally ill. Although the extent of this shift is debated, the high prevalence of mental illness in correctional settings is undisputed. 

Prison and Mental Health Reform

The Scope of the Problem

Many individuals with psychiatric problems end up in the arms of the law due to untreated symptoms that lead to criminal behavior. According to the Treatment Advocacy Center, individuals with severe mental illness are ten times more likely to be incarcerated than hospitalized, highlighting the systemic failure to provide appropriate community care. Once incarcerated, these individuals can face harsh environments, isolation, and limited access to care, leading to worsening symptoms. 

The Magnitude of Serious Mental Illness in U.S. Jails and Prisons

People with serious mental illness (SMI) are disproportionately incarcerated. While 6% of U.S. adults have a serious mental illness, their prevalence in correctional facilities is estimated to be three to four times higher. Los Angeles County Jail, Cook County Jail in Chicago, and Riker's Island Correctional Facility in New York house more individuals with mental illnesses than any psychiatric hospital in the U.S. Accordingly, 20% of jail and 15% of state prison inmates are diagnosed with a serious mental illness. This translates to roughly 383,000 inmates, nearly 10x the number of patients in state psychiatric hospitals.

Alternative to Incarceration and Prison Reform

Effective reform should focus on transitioning or diverting people with mental health issues out of and away from the legal system and into treatment. Initiatives such as crisis intervention and assertive community treatment teams can help individuals obtain care rather than incarceration.

Improving access to mental health services within prisons, training staff to recognize and respond to psychiatric crises, and implementing re-entry programs that include mental health support are crucial steps toward reducing recidivism and promoting public safety.

Successful Models and Advocacy

Programs like the Sequential Intercept Model offer a framework for preventing people with mental illness from entering or remaining in the criminal justice system. Advocacy groups such as the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) and the Sentencing Project work tirelessly to promote policies that support mental health care and humane treatment for incarcerated individuals.

Moving Forward

Mental health reform in prisons is not only a moral imperative but also a practical one. By prioritizing treatment over punishment, a more just and effective system can be created that supports and reduces re-offense and ultimately benefits society. 

Comprehensive Overview of Correctional Mental Health System

Mentally ill adults often become involved in the criminal justice system due to inadequate mental health support. Programs like crisis response training and mental health courts aim to divert them from deeper involvement. However, when diversion fails, they end up in jails and prisons.

Phases of Correctional Mental Health Care:

  1. Booking/Intake:
    • Competency evaluation for charges
    • Diagnosis, including substance abuse
    • Classification for safety and housing needs
  2. Confinement:
  3. Discharge:
    • Connection to community-based mental health programs

Funding and Administration

Correctional mental health care funding comes from government budgets, not federal programs like Medicaid or Medicare. The shift from state-funded asylums to county-funded jails and prisons has strained local resources. Recruitment challenges and inadequate infrastructure further complicate care delivery, particularly in rural areas. Telehealth and increased training have addressed these gaps, but systemic inefficiencies remain.

Legal Considerations

Incarcerated individuals have a constitutional right to mental health care under the Eighth Amendment, particularly for serious mental health needs. Legal rulings, such as Estelle v. Gamble, mandate care to prevent "cruel and unusual punishment." However, systems are not obligated to treat milder disorders unless they are linked to competency or safety concerns. Consent decrees and lawsuits have improved in some areas, but progress is inconsistent.

Ideas for Reform

  1. Prioritize Mental Health Treatment: Provide 24/7 access to mental health care, including evidence-based therapies like cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).
  2. Increase Funding: Governments should support correctional facilities providing mental health care, especially for serious conditions.
  3. Improve Data Collection: Accurate mental health prevalence and outcomes data is crucial for effective policy-making.
  4. Address Disparities: Implement culturally competent and trauma-informed care for racial and ethnic minorities.
  5. Expand Psychiatric Services: Repeal Medicaid’s Institutions for Mental Diseases exclusion to increase access to psychiatric beds and reduce the burden on jails.
  6. Create Specialized Units: Establish secure mental health step-down units for inmates with serious mental illnesses and a history of violence.
  7. Optimize Discharge Plans: Use long-acting medications during discharge to ensure continuity of care. Work with local mental health providers to provide quality care for incarcerated individuals.
  8. Support Reentry: Provide transition support programs and therapies to help inmates reintegrate into the community. Fund employment models that assist individuals with mental health disabilities find and retain jobs.
  9. Reduce Solitary Confinement: Invest in mental health housing and rehabilitation units to minimize the need for isolation.

Addressing the needs of seriously mentally ill individuals in correctional settings is essential for reducing recidivism, improving community safety, and upholding humane treatment standards. Effective reform will require coordinated efforts across government, healthcare, and community systems.

Additional Resources:

Blog Post

Research

Training

Podcast

Latest Business of Practice posts

Browse Business of Practice

Juvenile Life Without Parole (JLWOP)

Juvenile life without parole (JLWOP) is a sentence that places a child 17 years old or younger in prison for life without the possibility of parole.

Effects of Prison on the Family

Scope of the Problem The dramatic rise in incarceration rates in the United States since the 1970s has resulted in a significant increase in the

Destigmatizing Mental Health in Prisons

Destigmatizing mental health in prisons is a complex and multifaceted endeavor fraught with challenges. While it is a crucial step towards improving